Homes for Sale in Mayville, Wisconsin

About the city

Mayville has 5,196 residents. It sits along the Rock River and the Horicon Marsh and is often called the gateway to the marsh. The city is about an hour northwest of Milwaukee.

Schools

Mayville School District serves 944 students across three schools. Mayville High School enrolls just over 500, with a student to teacher ratio of about fifteen to one. The mascot is Big Red and teams are the Cardinals, competing in the Wisconsin Flyway Conference. The district has run a gifted and talented program since fourteen years before the state required one.

What the housing is like

Much of Mayville was built before World War Two, so the housing stock leans toward older homes with more architectural character and established neighborhoods.

Demand has outpaced supply. Industrial hiring in the area has grown faster than new housing. Inventory is tight, which matters to both buyers and sellers. The former downtown high school is being converted into a twenty unit apartment building called the Albrecht School Apartments, supported by a Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation award.

Market snapshot

As of July 2026, the median list price in Mayville was around $297,000, or about $162 per square foot, and homes were selling in a median of about nineteen days.

Market figures are a snapshot and change. For current numbers, ask Bridget.

Why people move here

Mayville sits along the Rock River and the Horicon Marsh and is often called the gateway to the marsh.

The Main Street Historic District has been on the National Register of Historic Places since 1995 and covers roughly seven acres of the old downtown.

What Bridget says about Mayville

I think what draws people to Mayville is that combination of a strong community and school district, older homes with character, and a price point that is still relatively affordable compared to some surrounding areas.

Search and valuation

Questions about Mayville